OpenAI has unveiled Sora, an advanced video-generating AI capable of creating short clips resembling gameplay. It has been speculated that OpenAI trained Sora on game content, including footage from popular video games. Released recently, the tool can generate 20-second videos from text prompts or images. The results include scenes that mimic iconic games like Super Mario Bros., first-person shooters inspired by titles such as Call of Duty, and arcade-style fighters. However, its potential training on game content has raised legal questions.
Sora seems adept at mimicking real-world gaming scenarios, even replicating the likeness of well-known Twitch streamers like Auronplay and Pokimane. This suggests that the model may have been trained on streaming platforms, including Twitch. Despite OpenAI’s efforts to block trademarked outputs, videos generated by Sora strongly resemble copyrighted games and content, pointing to extensive training data from gaming sources.
Legal and Copyright Complexities
OpenAI trained Sora on game content, and this has led to concerns over the potential misuse of intellectual property in the AI industry. Experts believe training AI on video game footage involves multiple layers of copyright protection. Video game content incorporates proprietary elements, including textures and characters, owned by developers. Additionally, unique recordings of gameplay often have copyrights held by content creators.
Evan Everist, a copyright law expert, emphasized the complexity of rights involved. A single game clip may have copyrights belonging to the developer, the video creator, and contributors of user-generated content, such as custom game maps. Without proper licensing, training on such materials may infringe on intellectual property rights.
Probabilistic Models and Risks
Generative AI models like Sora rely on probabilistic learning. They analyze patterns in vast datasets to make predictions. However, this can lead to unintended reproduction of copyrighted material. For instance, game-like videos created by Sora often resemble specific titles, which raises infringement concerns.
Legal professionals point to broader risks beyond copyright. Trademark violations and breaches of name, image, and likeness rights may also arise. The growing trend of “world models,” which can generate entire games in real time, adds another layer of complexity. If these synthetic games resemble copyrighted content, it could lead to legal challenges.
Fair Use Debate
By training Sora on game content, OpenAI has created an AI that can replicate various gaming styles and mechanics. The legal debate hinges on whether AI training constitutes “fair use.” Previous cases, such as Google Books’ digitization project, have considered transformative purposes as a defense. However, the unique nature of video game content complicates the issue.
Joshua Weigensberg, an intellectual property attorney, warned that training AI without proper licensing poses significant risks. Courts may view the use of proprietary game elements as copyright infringement, especially if the outputs closely resemble the training data.
Uncertain Future for AI and Copyright
The outcome of ongoing legal cases against generative AI companies will set critical precedents. Major lawsuits, such as those against AI art tools and music generators, will influence the gaming industry. Developers training AI on unlicensed footage could face exponential risk exposure due to overlapping copyright claims.
While OpenAI has remained vague about Sora’s training data, the company’s acknowledgment of using “publicly available” content raises questions. As generative AI tools like Sora evolve, addressing copyright, trademark, and licensing issues will remain a significant challenge for the tech industry.
Legal experts argue that game footage involves multiple layers of copyright protection. For example, game developers hold rights to the software and assets, streamers own the rights to their recorded playthroughs, and user-generated content adds another layer of ownership.
Also Read: Google Launches Project Mariner to Transform Online Experiences.
