• Send Us A Tip
  • Calling all Tech Writers
  • Advertise
TechStory
  • News
  • Crypto
  • Gadgets
  • Memes
  • Gaming
  • Cars
  • AI
  • Startups
  • Markets
  • How to
No Result
View All Result
SUBSCRIBE
TechStory
  • News
  • Crypto
  • Gadgets
  • Memes
  • Gaming
  • Cars
  • AI
  • Startups
  • Markets
  • How to
No Result
View All Result
TechStory
No Result
View All Result
Home Crypto

Former CFTC Commissioner suggests ETH can both be Security and Commodity

Reshab Agarwal by Reshab Agarwal
May 24, 2023
in Crypto, Ethereum, News
0
Tip creators on twitter

Credit: Programadores Brasil

215
SHARES
3.6k
VIEWS
TwitterWhatsappLinkedin

In a recent statement that has sent shockwaves through the cryptocurrency industry, a former commissioner of the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has suggested that Ethereum (ETH) can be classified as both a security and a commodity. This assertion by the former regulatory official has reignited the debate surrounding the regulatory status of cryptocurrencies, especially in the case of Ethereum, which is the second-largest digital asset by market capitalization. Let’s delve deeper into the implications of this statement and its potential impact on the crypto market.

You might also like

Tesla Autopilot Under Scrutiny: Fatal Crashes Prompt Calls for Regulation

OpenAI Investigates User Complaints as ChatGPT’s Responsiveness Faces Issues

Austin’s Aspirations as the Next Silicon Valley Threatened by Rising Challenges

Dual Classification

According to a former commissioner of the United States Commodities Futures Trading Commission, Ethereum’s native token, ETH, currently valued at $1,828, has the potential to be classified as both a commodity and a security.

Former CFTC Commissioner and former General Counsel at the Securities and Exchange Commission, Dan Berkovitz, stated during a recent episode of Laura Shin’s Unchained podcast on May 23 that Ethereum’s Ether (ETH) could potentially come under the regulatory purview of both agencies, implying the possibility of dual jurisdiction.

The prevailing ambiguity surrounding the legal classification of Ether can be attributed to conflicting statements issued by the CFTC and the SEC. In the past six months, the CFTC has consistently referred to Ether, along with several other cryptocurrencies, as a commodity.

Regulatory ambiguity: SEC’s Gary Gensler leaves Ether’s Legal status undefined

On the other hand, under the leadership of Gary Gensler, the SEC has not explicitly assigned a specific legal classification to Ether. During an oversight hearing in April, Gensler indicated that, apart from Bitcoin (BTC), which he acknowledged as a non-security, everything else should be considered security without providing further details or elaboration.

Despite the potential contradiction, Berkovitz highlighted that an asset like Ethereum could be classified as both a security and a commodity, citing the existence of overlapping legal definitions within the domains of commodities and securities. He said, “The law is clear. Something can actually be both a commodity and a security.”

The Complexity of Commodities: Berkovitz Sheds light on the definition and scope of “Commodities” in relation to Ether

Berkovitz clarified that the confusion stems from the fact that commodities extend beyond physical items such as “wheat” or “oats.” According to him, anything that is subject to a “futures contract” can be categorized as a commodity. This elucidates why the term “futures” is incorporated into the CFTC’s name.

Another perspective offered by Berkovitz suggests that security, as defined by the Securities Act and the Exchange Act, encompassing instruments like notes and investment contracts, can also become the underlying asset of a futures contract. Consequently, such securities would fall within the regulatory jurisdiction of the CFTC as well.

The primary focus of the CFTC lies in regulating futures and swaps related to commodities, whereas the SEC’s jurisdiction is solely dedicated to securities. However, if an asset qualifies as a commodity according to the CFTC and also meets the criteria of security according to the SEC’s definition, it is plausible for both regulatory bodies to exercise jurisdiction over it.

Critique of SEC’s Position

During the podcast, Collin Lloyd, a partner at the multinational law firm Sullivan & Cromwell, criticized the SEC’s assertion that all cryptocurrencies except Bitcoin should be classified as “securities” according to federal securities law.

Lloyd said, “I don’t see anything in the case law that tells me that some string of digits that operates on a blockchain can natively just be a security.”

“It’s kind of a weird question to be asking, ‘Is this digital asset a security or not?’ I think you should be asking, ‘Is this digital asset being sold as part of a securities transaction?’ That depends on the facts and circumstances.”

Significantly, Sullivan & Cromwell, which is presently involved in the FTX bankruptcy case, was enlisted by Coinbase on April 29 to provide assistance to the cryptocurrency exchange in its ongoing dispute with the SEC concerning ambiguous regulations.


In conclusion, the classification of Ethereum’s Ether (ETH) as both a security and a commodity remains a subject of debate. Former CFTC Commissioner Dan Berkovitz’s assertion that Ether can fall under the regulatory jurisdiction of both the SEC and CFTC highlights the complexity of defining cryptocurrencies within existing legal frameworks. The conflicting statements from regulatory bodies, such as the CFTC and SEC, contribute to the ongoing uncertainty surrounding Ether’s legal status.

Also Read: Japan to introduce stricter Crypto Anti-Money Laundering measures in June.

Tags: #CFTCEthereum
Tweet54SendShare15
Reshab Agarwal

Reshab Agarwal

Reshab is a tech-enthusiast who likes to write about all things crypto. He is a Bitcoin bull and believes in a decentralized future of finance. Follow him on Twitter for more!

Recommended For You

Tesla Autopilot Under Scrutiny: Fatal Crashes Prompt Calls for Regulation

by Harikrishnan A
December 11, 2023
0
Swedish Workers Unite Against Tesla in Unprecedented Labor Battle

In 2019, in Key Largo, a Tesla, which was driving on Autopilot, plowed into a car parked on the side of the road, killing the owners, a young...

Read more

OpenAI Investigates User Complaints as ChatGPT’s Responsiveness Faces Issues

by Harikrishnan A
December 11, 2023
0
Major Shift in OpenAI Leadership as CEO Sam Altman Departs Amid Resignations

User Frustrations Rise as ChatGPT Faces Criticism for Lackluster Performance OpenAI's latest version of ChatGPT, which is powered by their GPT-4 model, is under internal investigation following a...

Read more

Austin’s Aspirations as the Next Silicon Valley Threatened by Rising Challenges

by Harikrishnan A
December 11, 2023
0
Austin’s Aspirations as the Next Silicon Valley Threatened by Rising Challenges

Tech Exodus from Austin In recent years, Austin has emerged as a major contender to Silicon Valley's tech dominance. Austin has attracted major players like X (Twitter) and...

Read more
Next Post
Controversial Ledger Key Recovery Service Paused Amid Backlash

Controversial Ledger Key Recovery Service Paused Amid Backlash

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Nexcopy USB Duplicator

Make data loading to flash drives a simple process. Nexcopy USB Duplicator Systems.

Related News

How To Beat Escape from the Castle Claymount

How To Beat Escape from the Castle Claymount

December 2, 2023
How To Redeem Codes in Fortnite

How To Redeem Codes in Fortnite

December 5, 2023
How to Get Ashenvale Mount Season of Discovery

How to Get Ashenvale Mount Season of Discovery

December 5, 2023
Blooket

How to hack blooket

September 30, 2022
ARK Invest Reduces Exposure in Cryptocurrency Market, Sells $33M of Coinbase Shares and $5.9M of Grayscale Bitcoin Trust

ARK Invest Reduces Exposure in Cryptocurrency Market, Sells $33M of Coinbase Shares and $5.9M of Grayscale Bitcoin Trust

December 6, 2023
How To Update Minecraft Bedrock to 1.20.50

How To Update Minecraft Bedrock to 1.20.50

December 6, 2023

Techstory

Tech and Business News from around the world. Follow along for latest in the world of Tech, AI, Crypto, EVs, Business Personalities and more.
reach us at info@techstory.in

Advertise With Us

Reach out at info@techstory.in

BROWSE BY TAG

#Crypto acquisition AI amazon android Apple bitcoin Business China cryptocurrency e-commerce electric vehicles Elon Musk entrepreneurship Ethereum facebook flipkart funding Google India Instagram Investment ios iPhone IPO Market Markets Meta Microsoft News NFT Russia Social Media SpaceX startup startups tech Tech news technology Tesla TikTok trending twitter uber whatsapp

© 2023 Techstory Media Pvt Ltd

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Crypto
  • Gadgets
  • Memes
  • Gaming
  • Cars
  • AI
  • Startups
  • Markets
  • How to

© 2023 Techstory Media Pvt Ltd

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?