Indian policymakers view the risks AI poses to education as a unique concern, according to a survey conducted by OpenAI. While policymakers in other countries ranked education risks as less significant, Indian respondents placed them higher than geopolitical or alignment-related threats. The study, carried out from September to December 2023, surveyed policymakers from India, Japan, Taiwan, the U.K., and the U.S. The OpenAI study finds AI in education will be a major risk in India, citing concerns about students’ over-reliance on AI tools.
According to experts, the OpenAI study finds AI in education will be a major risk in India due to its potential to undermine critical thinking skills. Despite OpenAI’s findings, experts in government, academia, and industry disagree. They argue that the perceived risks in education are overstated and fail to recognize AI’s potential to transform learning in India. Critics believe these concerns arise from limited awareness and understanding of generative AI technologies.
One key concern raised in the survey was students’ potential decline in critical thinking. With generative AI providing instant answers, the fear is that students may rely too heavily on these tools, compromising original thought. Additionally, educators worry that AI use could lead to testing systems evaluating AI-generated responses instead of students’ understanding.
Opportunities Outweigh Challenges
Experts like Advitiya Sharma of Schoolnet and Krishnan Narayanan of IIT Madras highlight the benefits of generative AI in education. These include enhancing learning outcomes, encouraging student engagement, and offering a productive alternative to social media. Sharma suggested that widespread AI adoption in the next two years could significantly reduce the current perception of risks.
Krishnan Narayanan advocates for designing AI systems that encourage students to arrive at answers themselves, rather than providing them outright. He views generative AI as a valuable tool for co-creating knowledge and promoting curiosity.
Experts stress the need for appropriate regulations to prevent biased AI systems. Amar Patnaik, a former Rajya Sabha MP, warns against over-reliance on flawed datasets and emphasizes the inclusion of informal sector data to create balanced AI models.
A Boon for Digital Learning
The OpenAI study finds that AI in education will be a major risk in India because it may change how students are assessed in schools. But AI in education offers vast opportunities to democratize access to quality resources, particularly in underserved areas. Sharma shared examples of AI tools being tested in Jharkhand schools, showing promise in scaling world-class education.
While education risks were emphasized, experts noted that other pressing concerns, such as AI’s role in military applications or climate change, require attention. These areas, they argue, could have far-reaching implications if left unaddressed. AI tools have the potential to revolutionize Indian education by making learning engaging and accessible. However, experts agree that thoughtful implementation and robust regulations are critical to maximizing benefits while addressing risks.
Challenges of AI in Education: A Double-Edged Sword
The primary concern raised in the OpenAI survey revolves around the decline in critical thinking skills. If students become overly dependent on AI tools for answers, they may bypass the cognitive processes essential for problem-solving and creativity. Additionally, educators fear the need to overhaul traditional assessment methods, as AI-generated responses might overshadow genuine student input.
Another significant challenge is the potential for AI tools to amplify biases embedded in their training data. In a diverse country like India, where informal sectors contribute a wealth of unstructured data, excluding such information could result in skewed AI outputs. These issues demand careful consideration of the ethical and practical implications of integrating AI into classrooms.
Also Read: Microsoft Is Forcing Its AI Assistant on People, Sparking User Backlash.
